2007 Best Animated Short
Channel Frederator Blog

I don’t really like to rant on this blog. That’s not what it’s about, but I think there is something wrong with today’s rules in regards to the Best Animated Short category.
Look at the list of potential winners for 2007:
The Danish Poet by Torill Kove (NFB)
Everything Will Be OK by Don Hertzfeldt
Family Ties: Dreams & Desires by Joanna Quinn
Guide Dog by Bill Plympton
Lifted by Gary Rydstrom (Pixar)
Little Match Girl by Roger Allers (Disney)
Maestro directed by Géza M Toth
No Time for Nuts directed by Chris Renaud & Mike Thurmeier (Blue Sky)
Tragic Story with Happy Ending by Regina Pessoa
One Rat Short by Alex Weil
The problem as I see it is in this part of the rules for the Oscars:
V. TELEVISION AND INTERNET TRANSMISSIONS
Feature Documentaries and Short Subject Documentaries
NO TYPE of television or internet transmission shall occur at any time prior to and for two months after the first day of the Qualifying Exhibition, or at any time before the film has completed its multi-city Theatrical Roll-Out.As indicated in ¶IV.4.b, i f a short documentary qualifies by the seven-day Qualifying Exhibition only, it must be withheld from television or the internet for six months following the day nominations are announced.
For studios with hundreds of people and millions of dollars behind them, it’s easy to get their films seen by millions of people by including it on a DVD release for a different film. Both Blue Sky and Disney did this with their shorts (available on “Ice Age 2″ and “The Little Mermaid Special Edition”).
My question is this: How are filmmakers who work on a smaller scale supposed to be able to compete with the larger stuios?
Based on the official rules, they aren’t allowed to show their films online, yet online distribution via YouTube, DailyMotion, (or better yet) our own Channel Frederator Podcast is one of the only ways they can (within their budgets) reach the same number of viewers as one of the big studios’ DVD releases.
Does the online showing of a film somehow lessen it’s artistic merit? Is it different than a DVD release of a short? If so, how? What about bootleg versions of a film showing up online? Should they disqualify a film from the Oscars? Should the category be split between independents and studio films?
What are your thoughts on this?
Good luck to everyone who is in the running, big or small.





![[large][black] FReDERATOR badge](http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3502/3317571331_e33068a3c8_m.jpg)










